Showing posts with label Finances. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Finances. Show all posts

Thursday, November 1, 2012

9 money rules to live by


Most surveys that measure financial literacy focus on teenagers, and the results are always grim.

In research by the nonprofit Jump$tart Coalition, which promotes personal finance education, the average high school student correctly answered just 48.3% of the questions covering money basics in 2008. That was down from 57.3% a decade earlier, but even that score was hardly distinguishing -- anything less than 60% counts as an F.

A 2005 poll by Harris Interactive for the National Council on Economic Education showed that adults aren't that much savvier.

While teens on average scored a 53 (another F) on a quiz testing knowledge of basic economic and personal-finance concepts, the grownups' average score was just 70 (a C).

In addition:

  • More than one-quarter of adults failed the quiz.
  • Women were far more likely to fail than men; 42% scored an F, compared with 15% of men.
  • Men were much more likely than women to get an A or B on the test (51% compared with 17%).

If it makes you female readers feel any better, there are also lots of studies out there showing that we're better investors than men -- once we get around to investing.

But the fact remains that there's a heck of a lot of financial ignorance going around, and financial ignorance is costly. Women may have even more to lose than men, since we tend to earn less, are more likely to have interrupted careers and live longer, which means we have more time to suffer from our mistakes.

My email box and Facebook page bear testimony to the daily cost of financial illiteracy: men and women who are overwhelmed by debt or have no savings, or don't invest for retirement, or fall for investment scams, or think we can drive gas prices down by not buying fuel for a day.


Understanding economics and personal finance doesn't mean you won't make mistakes or face financial disasters. But you can lessen the odds and repair the damage faster if you know the rules of the game.

Here are the economic and financial concepts I wish everybody knew:


  1. The difference between needs and wantsOur actual needs are pretty limited: food, shelter, clothing, companionship. Just about everything else is a "want," and our wants are essentially endless. Because our resources are limited (see "scarcity," below), we have to make choices about which wants to fulfill.

    Also, the way we fulfill our needs involves a lot of choice. Shelter, for example, can be a bed at a mission for the homeless or a $125 million mansion. Our food choices offer a similar range, from beans and tap water consumed at home to steak and Dom Perignon at an exclusive restaurant.

    I've discovered many people believe they have to spend money in certain ways or in certain amounts, when in reality their spending is a choice -- or is at least based on choices they made earlier. If you're facing a monster mortgage payment, for example, it's because you chose to buy that home and selected that particular mortgage.

    Taking responsibility for our choices can be scary, but it should also be empowering. After all, if you have choices, you're not just a victim of circumstance.

  2. Scarcity makes your choices for youIt's lovely to believe in a world of endless abundance, but the reality is that at any given point in time, our resources have limits. Whether it's oil in the ground, our time here on Earth or the cash in our pockets, there's only so much available to be spent.

    People who ignore this reality are the ones who run out of paycheck before they run out of month, or who extend their unsustainable spending by relying on credit cards, home equity loans and other reckless borrowing. Their refusal to make the sometimes-hard choices needed to responsibly manage money means that they will have even fewer choices in the future. The money they spend on stuff and on interest can't be invested in other goals, like retirement, so odds are pretty good they'll wind up old and broke.

  3. The pointlessness of the hedonic treadmillThis isn't the latest workout device at your gym. The hedonic treadmill means that we quickly adjust to improved circumstances. A raise at work or a new possession may make us happy for a little while, but we soon take our situation for granted. Our expectations continue to rise: If only I could get another raise, or a better car, or a bigger house. Should those expectations be satisfied, again we'd adjust and quickly want more.

    This has a lot of implications for personal finance and the economy, but here's something to consider: Maybe we need to look beyond our wallets for true happiness.

  4. Every money decision has a cost of its own
    "Opportunity cost," very simply, means what we give up to get something else. In every choice, there's an opportunity cost. If you decide to go to college, for example, you're giving up the income you could have earned by working full-time during those years plus whatever you could have purchased with the money used to attend school. You also may take on loans to pay for school, which will have to be paid back with future income that could have gone for other purposes.

    The good news, of course, is that even with opportunity costs, college is a slam-dunk for most people. The average college graduate makes about 70% more over his or her lifetime than someone who stops with a high school diploma.

    If, however, you train for a career that has little demand and wind up making the same amount as a high school grad or trailing huge amounts of student loan debt you can never repay, you may regret the money spent on school and the foregone income.

    Understanding that our choices have opportunity costs, and examining what those costs are, should help us make better economic decisions.

  5. Why supply and demand rule
    For the most part, prices are set by the interaction between supply and demand. If demand for something suddenly shoots up and the available supply of that something doesn't change, then prices will increase. If demand drops or supply increases, prices typically fall.

    Here's an example. Say rock star Brittany Amber Tiffany is photographed wearing a cap with the brand name of a Midwestern seed company. Suddenly, all her fans and half the people reading Us magazine decide they, too, need the Midwestern seed company's hat. The farm supply companies that stock these hats figure out a good thing when they see it, and double, then triple, the price. The hat actually worn by Brittany sells for a mint on eBay, earning a notice in mainstream newspapers and furthering the craze.

    The Midwestern seed company wants a piece of this action and starts cranking out hats by the ton. Suddenly you can find one in every Target and Wal-Mart. The retailers can no longer command a premium for having a rare item, thanks to the increase in supply. In fact, the hats start seeming a heck of a lot less cool, lowering demand; Target and Wal-Mart slash the price still further to get rid of their unwanted supply.

    The interplay of supply and demand is also why one-day gas boycotts don't work. Even if a lot of people participated, overall demand wouldn't change; the boycotters would likely gas up before or after the selected day. Only a big increase in supply or a sustained decline in demand is likely to affect prices.

    Supply and demand have a lot to do with our incomes as well. If we have rare skills that are in high demand by employers, we can negotiate higher pay. If, on the other hand, a lot of people can do what we do or the employer need for what we do is limited, our incomes are likely to be stunted.

  6. Throw no good money after bad
    "Sunk costs" are expenses that have already been incurred and can't be recovered to any appreciable extent. "Sunk cost fallacy" means an irrational belief that a further investment of time, money or effort will somehow resurrect the value that's already disappeared.

    A classic example is the investor whose stock has plunged because the prospects of the company have worsened. The investor wouldn't buy the same stock today, yet continues to hang on to the shares rather than sell them and take the loss. The investor may offer the excuse that he or she wants to at least "break even" before selling, but of course the stock market doesn't care about the investor getting the money back, and all the wishing in the world won't bring the stock price back up.

    By hanging on to the shares, the investor is giving up the opportunity to invest elsewhere at a profit -- an opportunity cost.

  7. The role risk plays
    Every human endeavor carries some risk, and investments are no exception. What differs is the amount and type of risk and how you're compensated for taking it.

    The 30-day Treasury bill, for example, is one of the "safest" investments around if you're solely concerned with getting back your original investment. The T-bill is backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. But the average return on a 30-day T-bill over the past 80 years is just 3.7%, according to Ibbotson Associates. That's just above the historical 3% inflation rate for the same period; if you factor in taxes, you probably lost money.

    Large-company stocks, by contrast, returned an average 10.4% annually during the same period. That handily beats inflation, but as everyone who has invested in the past decade knows, stocks aren't a sure thing. There were plenty of years along the way that the market for large-company stocks dived, and if you invested all your money in a single stock -- say, Enron -- you could have been wiped out. That's called market risk.

    Here's what you should take away: You'll almost certainly need to take some market risk if you want to grow your wealth and beat inflation over time. But you should also be wary of anyone who "guarantees" a high return on an investment. If you're earning much more than the going rate on a T-bill, you're taking some risk, and you should understand that risk before proceeding.

  8. The time value of moneyThis boils down to a relatively simple proposition: that the dollar I get today is worth more than a dollar I'm promised sometime in the future.

    There are several reasons for this. One is the "bird in the hand" reality: The dollar I get today is real, but the dollar I'm promised in the future likely will be worth less (because of inflation), or I might not get it at all (you might renege on your promise to give it to me, or die, or cease operations if you're an employer or business). Also, the dollar I get today can be invested to create more dollars in the future.

    Turn this around, and you'll see why lenders charge interest for loaning money -- and why the interest rate depends on your creditworthiness. Lenders want to be compensated for the erosion in their dollars due to inflation, and for the risk of lending money to you.

    The higher the perceived rate of future inflation and the more lenders doubt your promise to pay the money back, the more interest they'll charge to compensate for the risk.

  9. The miracle of compound interest
    This is a concept best illustrated by example. Let's say I give you a penny today, and promise to double the amount every day for a full month. How much money would I be giving you on the 31st day?

    The answer: $10.7 million.

    Each day, the "interest" I paid you the previous day earns more interest. At the beginning, the amounts are nominal, but by the end we're talking big bucks.

    Of course, no one's going to double your money every day. But this concept explains how people who save relatively small amounts over the years can build rather substantial nest eggs. After a few decades, their actual contributions represent only a small part of their burgeoning wealth -- it's mostly their returns that are earning returns.

    But this also illustrates how debts can quickly balloon out of control. If you're paying interest, rather than incurring it, and you're not diligent about paying off the finance charges in full every month, the unpaid amount will incur additional interest charges, increasing the total amount that you owe. This is why so many families who incur credit card debt eventually find themselves in trouble as the amounts they owe explode past their ability to pay.

    There are plenty more nifty and helpful money concepts, but these nine are among my favorites.



Liz Weston is the Web's most-read personal-finance writer. She is the author of several books, most recently "The 10 Commandments of Money: Survive and Thrive in the New Economy" (find it on Bing). Weston's award-winning columns appear every Monday and Thursday, exclusively on MSN Money. Click here to find Weston's most recent articles.

Connect with Weston on Facebook here.


http://money.msn.com/how-to-budget/9-money-rules-to-live-by-weston.aspx

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Money Management Part Nine - Retirement Planning


This is a short post.  I will not make any claims to being an investment expert, and you should talk to a professional about retirement and estate planning.  But I didn't want to leave everything hanging with my friends Jack and Jill - I wanted to see them through to the end and find out where they would end up.  So, here is a brief recap of their timeline and a trajectory for their future:



Jack and Jill’s Timeline

June 2010 – bought their house and bought appliances on 18 month no-interest, no-payments plan
June 2011 – Richard gets them to track spending for a month.  (Kids are 2 & 4.)
July 2011 – They collect their credit reports and debt information to understand their financial picture.
August 2011 – Jill starts working from home part-time, and their new budget is implemented.
November 2011 – They worked hard and paid off their furniture account before the interest came due.
December 2011/January 2012 – Jill banked her $500/month for their emergency fund.
December 2012 – They have paid off Line of Credit, MC and Visa by now.
October 2013 – They have paid off Student Loan and Car and are now debt-free aside from their mortgage.
October 2014 – In one year they have banked six months of expenses.  Now they start investing for retirement and college.  (Kids are five and seven.)
January 2015 – They implement a new plan to pay down the mortgage using Jack’s raise.

Let's look at the future...

May 2022 – Their mortgage is paid off, thirteen years early and with over $50,000 interest saved.
June-August 2022 – They celebrate by saving for and enjoying a great family vacation (kids are now 11 and 13).

September 2022 – Now that they are no longer paying $1310.33 on their mortgage every month, they increase retirement investment to $1000/month, and the college accounts to $400/month.   To date, the retirement account currently has $111,360 and the college account has $26,202.  They have $960.33 per month freed up to do wish as they wish.  Their first goal is saving for Jill and the kids to travel to an African orphanage and work their for three months.  Jack will join them for four weeks, using his vacation time from work.  They also start saving for their next car purchase.

September 2027 - $78,618 has accumulated in the college account.  The kids are now 18 & 20.  18-year-old Bobby decides to attend college, while 20-year-old Sue has a small wedding and buys a house.  College is paid for in full with a half-share of $39,309 with plenty to spare.  He decides to take some of the remainder and by a car, which he gets a discount on for paying cash, and to put the rest in the bank for his own emergency fun.  The wedding and house downpayment are covered by the other half.  Way to be free from the start!


Onward to retirement...


RETIREMENT SCENARIO #1
December 2045 – Jack is 65.  After investing $1000/month for the last 23 years since the mortgage was paid off, the retirement account now has $2,844,602.  He decides to keep working half-time til age 70.  Cut investment amount to $500/month for five more years.

December 2050.  Merry Christmas, Jack and Jill.  Jack retires at age 70 with $5,053,712 in the retirement investments.  They move the money into an account with 2.25% interest compounded daily.  The interest on the account pays them $108,537 per year without touching the principal, which they excitedly plan to disburse as part of their estate to their children, grandchildren and several charities.

RETIREMENT SCENARIO #2
December 2045 – Jack is 65.  Retirement account has $2,844,602.  They move the money into an account with 2.25% interest compounded daily.  The interest on the account pays them $ 61,092 per year without touching the principal.  He supplements this income by working part-time, and with a small pension.

RETIREMENT SCENARIO #3
December 2045 – Jack is 65.  Retirement account has $2,844,602.   He stops investing additional money, but leaves the investment active.  The annual interest earned on the investment is $341,352, which even after taxes provides them with a very comfortable living.  (Especially since they have no mortgage or debt.)  They have the time, energy and money to enjoy their growing family, and look forward to an annual family vacation.  They re-invest lump sums on occasion, and have designed their final wishes to ensure their grandchildren’s educations and their children a head-start on their own retirement savings.  (Not that they’ll need it.)

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Money Management Part Eight - Free and Clear

January 2015.  Jack and Jill now have kids who are six and eight years old.  In the last five years they have paid off all their consumer debt, their car and Jack's student loan.  They have established a $1,000 emergency fund in the bank and have over $18,000 in a money market fund that they can access in case of a financial or family crisis.  They have started investing for their retirement and for their kids' education.  Jill is still doing some bookkeeping work from home, bringing in about $500 per month.  And Jack's career is doing well.  He just received a promotion and with it a small raise that brings his income to $67,000 per year, or $5583.33 per month.  He and Jill are discussing what they should do with this extra money.   Jack suggests calling Richard and Jane to come over for a visit.  They've just returned from spending three months on a third-world missions trip, and the friends have been meaning to get together anyway.

"Hey, Richard!"  Jack greets his friend.  "How are things going?"

"Fine, fine, thanks for asking.  And you guys?  How's life treating you?"

"Great!  I just landed a promotion, in fact.  Jill and I were just discussing what we should do with the extra income, and of course your name came up."

"Well, you've been at this for a while now.  What do you think you should do with it?"

"There are a couple of options.  The car is coming on what, seven years old now.  It's soon going to need to be replaced.  We could increase our investing.  We could use it to pay for sports for the kids..."

"Can I make a suggestion?"

"Please do!"

"Throw it at your mortgage.  That's the last thing holding you back from real financial freedom.  You've taken care of everything else - now it's time to take on the dragon.  How much of a raise are you talking about here?"

"$483.33 per month."

"That will make a nice dent.  Remember that spreadsheet we were using for your debt snowball?  Get that out and start punching in numbers, and see if you don't find some motivation."

They chatted a bit longer, than Jack went to find Jill and the spreadsheet.  They sat down together and started filling in numbers, playing out 'what-if' scenarios and coming up with some interesting results.  When Richard and Jane arrived, they jumped right in.

"If we put this whole raise onto your mortgage, and you just continue as you've been...." Richard looked up.  "What other sources of income would you consider throwing against this?"

"Income tax refunds seem like an obvious choice,"  Jack replied.  "I know a lot of my co-workers use that money for RRSPs, but at the rate we're already investing, I'm happier to use it to get us closer to financial freedom."

"Sounds good to me, too."  Richard nodded, filled in some numbers, then brought out his computer.  Now let's take a look at this.  Right now, continuing your mortgage payment according to your contract, you'll have it paid off in April 2035.  And you'll pay a total of $111,849.18 in interest."

"Ouch - that's practically paying for the house twice!"  Jill was surprised.

"Don't I know it," Richard agreed.  "'But let's start doing the math.  We'll assume a $4,000 tax refund each April, plus another $5799.96 each year from Jack's new raise.  That's $9,799.96 paid in a lump on your mortgage each April.  Depending on the terms of your mortgage, you might be able to make extra payments more often, but we'll assume right now that you can only do so once a year."  He put the numbers into the computer.  "Now, take a look at this!"

"Unreal!"  Jack blurted out, amazed.  "We just saved... is that right?  Over $50,000 in interest?"

"Yup.  Not to mention cutting thirteen years off your mortgage.  By this plan, you'll have your house paid off in 2022 - just seven years from now, instead of twenty.  That's harnessing the power of compound interest and putting it to work for you instead of against you.  By steadily reducing the balance, you are slowly and steadily reducing the amount of interest that is accumulating.  You can make this even better if you invest that $483.33 every month in something that will earn you interest, then withdraw the balance in April to pay it onto your mortgage each year.  Every dollar counts!"

"Niiiiiice."  Jack looked thoughtful.  "I wonder what else we could do with this?"

"And what we could do after this!" Jill exclaimed.  "That would free up another $827.00 each month that we could use to crank up the kids' college accounts, to buy a vehicle..."

"Or to be more generous than you've ever been able to be in your life!"  Jane cut in.  "That's the final step on this journey - once you are no longer a slave to debt, and you become master of your money, then you can do the things you've never been able to do before.  Cut your work hours and spend time volunteering.  Make donations to charity that you've always wished you could.  Go on a missions trip.  Adopt sponsored children.  The sky is the limit!"  It was obvious how passionate Jane was, and how much she loved their new, debt-free life.  They still lived simply by some standards, but they had everything they needed, some of what they wanted, and they were free from the stresses that held so many of their friends back from living fully.

"You know what, I think I finally get it," Jack said thoughtfully.  "I had wondered so often what it was that was different about you guys. You always seem so... content.  This is it, isn't it?  You found freedom."

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Money Management Part Seven - Investing for Future Goals

A year later, Jack and Jill had paid off all their debt except their mortgage, and had accumulated over $18,000 in savings.  Their feeling of freedom was growing by the day, and their financial stress was so much less than it had been just a few years before.  They had been enjoying social times with Richard and Jane through the year, but it was now time for another "official" meeting.  Jill phoned Jane.  "Pizza night tonight?"

"Sounds great - should we bring the books?"  Jane laughed.  "I bet I know what we're going to talk about after supper!"

"You got it.  See you around six?  I'll get the dough together - can you bring some toppings?"

"Sure thing- it's a date.  See you then!"

After supper the kids settled in to enjoy a video together and the adults settled in to work on the next stage of the plan.

"So - what's next?"  Jack asked.  "Where we are today is so far removed from where we started, I know that we should trust whatever you tell us to do!"  Jill nodded in agreement.

"Well this is where it starts to get fun.  We are going to start building some wealth for your future."  Richard laid out a new copy of their budget.  Jack noticed there was a new category added - Investments, $850.00.


"What's this?" Jack asked.

"That is your investment in your future.  Now that you've got no debt, and you've got some comfortable savings, it's time to plan ahead.  First, we get you putting 15% of your income into longer-term investments."  Richard paused.  "Think for a minute.  Five years ago, could you imagine this being possible?"

"No way.  We had too much money tied up in payments and interest.  It would have sounded like a cruel joke if you'd even suggested it."  Jack looked down at the paper and then back up.  "But here you've got it sorted out so it's not just possible, but there's even money left over!"

"Gotta love it, eh?"  Richard sat back in his chair.  "I've got some investment people that I like to work with and they've treated us really well.  I'll hook you up and get you on track.  Something you need to really pay attention to is your rate of return vs inflation, and these guys are great at that sort of thing."

"Return vs inflation?  What difference does that make?"  Jill asked.

"That is something most people don't even think about.  Inflation has averaged about 3% in Canada.  In order to actually come ahead on your investments, your return has to be more than that.  If you're investing at 2%, and inflation is 3%, then you're actually losing 1% on your investments."

"Scary.  Suddenly those so-called high-interest bank accounts out there that are offering up to 3% interest don't sound like such a great deal anymore."  Jill sighed.  "So, what do you recommend?"

"I recommend you get involved with a professional, and I'll get you the name of my guy before we leave tonight.  But in general, look for solid investments that have a long track record of performance.  You don't have money that you can afford to risk losing, so you want to stay away from the investments that might be just a flash in the pan then disappear.  Mutual funds can be a pretty good investment.

Here's something pretty cool I heard today on Dave Ramsey's radio show.  If you start at age thirty, investing $600.00 every month until age seventy, with no panicking.  Have 'Nerves of Steel' he says.  You keep doing that, in an investment with an average annual return of 12%, and you'll have seven million dollars for retirement."

"Wow.  Now that's something."  Jack was impressed.  "Well, I'm not thirty anymore, but we're looking at more than $600, so maybe it will balance out for us in the end.  I'd be happy to see half that much in the bank at retirement!"

"You said it, friend.  I ran the numbers for you on this one - you're 35, and let's assume you work for 30 years and keep up this monthly investment, earning 12% per year.  You'll have $2,644,293 to retire at age 65.  But if you go five more years, you'll nearly double your investment. $4,729,086.  So stay in good shape, eh?"   Richard smiled, sipping on a fresh coffee.  "There's one other thing you need to look at today.  Look at the next line on the budget."

"College.  But they're still little, just five and seven!  We don't need to worry about that now, do we?"  Jill looked uncertain.  "And what if they don't go to college?"

"This is something else for you to discuss with a pro, but you'll be looking for some of the same things.  A good rate of return is key.  Some investments offer matching, but some of those have some wicked fees attached.  You'll want to make an informed decision on this one.  If you want flexibility in what they can use the money for, maybe an RESP isn't the best option.  Look at what's available, and get started.  I put $200 in that spot, but you can increase it later if you get another raise.  If you're wondering, that will give you over $45,000 ten years from now when your first child is ready to talk about college.  $62,000 two years later.  Split that between them, and you've got a good head start on university, or a college education paid for, or a downpayment on a house, or a wedding... you'll be set for whatever path they choose.  And that's assuming you haven't increased those deposits by then."  Richard grinned at Jack.  "I also increased your allowances a bit."

Jack laughed.  "You mean, I can stop taking peanut butter to work every day?"



Additional Reading:
Get Smarter About Money: Investing
Dave Ramsey's Investing Philosophy
Investment Returns

Online Tools:
Bank of Canada's Investment Calculator
Savings & Investment Calculators
FundLibrary.com Canada's Mutual Fund Resources Centre

Investment Options to Consider:
Tax Free Savings Accounts
RESP
RRSPs and Related Plans

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Money Management Part Six - A Financial Safety Net

Summer drew to a close and fall came to visit.  Jack and Jill stuck with the plan and managed to pay off their appliances a few days before the loan came due.  "What a relief!!" Jill exclaimed as she spoke to Jane on the phone that evening.  "And you know, the clerk seemed almost disappointed to accept that final payment.  But we celebrated all the way home.  It's nice to know that we dodged that one... the next statement would have been a real shock!"

"Definitely.  I'm so glad you made it in time.  You're making great progress already!  Are you all set for Christmas?"

"We decided to keep Christmas simple this year.  We've been focused and we've made progress that we're really proud of.  But I have to admit that it is really tempting to go find those cards and make the kids' Christmas dreams come true."

"Are they the kids' dreams, or are they your dreams?"  Jane asked.  And Jill knew her friend was right.  She knew that her kids were young enough that they would be happy with whatever they received, but inside she still felt a little guilty knowing that their friends would be getting the latest and greatest.  And she really wanted to do something special for Jack.

"Just keep pressing on, Jill - you are doing so well.  By this time next year, you'll be a completely different place and you'll be so glad you didn't give in to this temptation!  What do you say we take a break, get away from the commercialism for a while?  Let's take the kids sliding and then come back to our place for cocoa?  We can talk about how you're doing and set you on track for your next goal."

"Sounds good to me - how's two o'clock?"

"Great!"

After a few hours outdoor, everyone was tired but happy.  The kids enjoyed some cocoa then retreated to the playroom while the adults stayed in the kitchen to talk.  Jane invited them to stay for supper and started a big batch of spaghetti for everyone while chatting with Jill.  The men took their coffee to the table.

"So, Jane tells me you've got reason to celebrate!"  Richard sat back with his coffee and looked at Jack expectantly.

"Absolutely!"  Jack nodded. "We got that appliance loan paid off just in the nick of time!  Now we're ready to press forward... once Christmas is over, of course."

"What do you mean?" Richard leaned forward.

"Well, you know... Christmas is expensive and all... seems unrealistic to try to keep up like this through December... don't you think?"  Jack hesitated.

"Absolutely - if you're still stuck in the old thought patterns.  Sure, it would be easy to grab a card or two and take care of Christmas the way you want to, but what would the long-term effect of that be?  Don't you think financial freedom is a better gift to yourselves and your kids?"

"Well.... yeah.... of course..."  Jack knew his friend was right, but he was conflicted.  After all, he wanted Jill to enjoy her Christmas morning, and the kids needed nice gifts too, didn't they?   Just then, Jill came over.

"Is there an echo in here?  Jane and I were having the same conversation just a few hours ago!"  She laughed softly and shook her head.  "It really is easy to lose track, isn't it?  Just like falling off the wagon."

Jack looked up at her.  "But... Jill, how will we pay for Christmas if we keep up like this?  I know we agreed to keep it simple, but... "  He pulled out his wallet.  "I've only got $60 in here.  That's not going to go very far."

Jill smiled.  "It turns out that we planned for this.  Even I didn't realize it at the time, but we did!  Jane and I were just chatting and she showed me something - when she set up our budget and debt plan, Jane didn't assign my 'baby cheque' income to anything, and we've been so focused on keeping the budget that I haven't needed to spend it.  That, combined with little savings here and there over the past months, gives us more than enough for Christmas.  We've actually got cash available!"

Jack looked incredulous for a moment, then grinned.  "No way.  Really?  That's unbelievable!  We've never paid cash for Christmas before!"

Richard laughed.  "Welcome to freedom, my friends!  Now, are you ready to take the next step?"  They both nodded eagerly.  "Great - let's have a look at where we are now."    Jack pulled out the sheet with their budget and handed it to Richard, who made a few changes.  "Here's your plan of attack for January - you'll follow this until April when the MasterCard is paid off and then revise it again.  And again.  And again, until all your debts are paid off."


Food $    500.00
Mortgage $    827.00
Property Tax $    150.00
House Insurance $    100.00
Utilities (Heat, Electricity) $    100.00
Other Bills (Phone, Internet, Cable, Cellular) $    200.00
Clothing $      40.00
Automobile Costs (Gas, Repair, Licenses) $    100.00
Car Payment $    280.00
Health/Dental Care $    140.00
Recreation/Hobbies/Entertainment $    100.00
Household (including furniture, supplies, repairs, lawn care, etc) $    100.00
Miscellaneous $      40.00
Gifts  $      40.00
Payroll Deductions (Tax, EI, CPP) $ 1,168.59
Debt Payments
Line of Credit $    270.00
MasterCard $    662.00
Visa $      90.00
Student Loan $    155.00
Jill's Allowance $      20.00
Jack's Allowance $      40.00
Charitable Giving $    393.14
 $ 5,515.73


"That will be so incredible," Jill said.  "I can't wait!"

"Me, either," agreed Jack.  "I have plans for that extra cash!!"   He looked at Richard.  "Er, I mean... what are our plans for that cash?"   They all laughed.

"Well, like I asked you before, is a thousand dollars in the bank enough?  Will that see you through if you get sick and need to take a month off work, or if there is a family emergency that you have to take care of, or if something major goes wrong with the car?  How long will that little fund last you if you have a real emergency?"  Richard looked at Jack intently.

"Hmm.  Not very long.  That wouldn't even cover our mortgage and food for a month."

"Exactly.  So your next step is to create a financial safety net for yourselves.  But for now, you focus on getting these debts paid off.   Say, have you given any thought to your tax refund in the spring?"

"Actually, yes - it should be about $3,800 - and we've already decided that we'll take the whole thing and pay it on our debts."  Jack nodded.

"Awesome - do you know what kind of impact that will have?"  Richard pulled up his computer and opened up a spreadsheet.  He changed a few numbers, then turned back with a grin.  "You just saved yourselves another four months of payments, not to mention saving even more interest."

As the months passed, Jack and Jill stuck with the plan with increasing commitment.  As each debt reached a zero balance, they continued to roll the payments onto the next debt until finally the day came in December 2012 when they paid the final installment on their line of credit.  Christmas was simple again that year, then on New Year's Day they celebrated with a bonfire, toasting marshmallows and drinking cocoa while burning all their old statements.

"What a feeling.  This is incredible!" Jill gushed.  "I would have never, ever imagined we could manage this.  We've paid off over $17,000 in just over a year.  That's amazing!"

"You are doing great," Jane agreed.  "Two more to go - and they will go so fast now!  By the end of this year, you will be debt-free, without even a car payment!"

And so they were.  October rolled around and with it the final payment on the car.  Jack and Jill celebrated that night with a rare night out for the family, taking the kids for pizza and a movie.  Since they didn't do these things very often anymore, it was a real treat for everyone.

The next day, they got together with Richard and Jane again.

"Can I just say, we are so proud of you guys."  Richard opened the door and handed Jill a bouquet of flowers.  He shook Jack's hand and directed them to the living room where Jane had some papers spread out on the coffee table.

"What's all this?"  Jill asked.

"Just a refresher for you... a reminder of what could have been and what you made of it instead.  Remember the minimum-payments scenario?"

"Ugh... absolutely.  Thank you, both of you, for helping us avoid all of that!"

"No problem - it's what we do!"  Jane smiled at her friend.  "Now, are you ready for the next step?"

Jack sat down.  "Lay it on us."  

"All righty then...."  Richard came in with some snacks and a fresh notebook.  "Time to move forward!"

"The next thing we want to do is get your financial safety net in place.  Generally speaking, this should be three to six months worth of expenses, in a bank account or investment that can be withdrawn on short notice without penalty, like a money market fund."

"Six months??  There's no way!"  Jack shook his head.  "How could we do that?"

"The same way you paid off your debt - with commitment, consistency, and intensity."  Richard opened the notebook.  "I've got it sketched out for you here.  Take a look.

"You started out paying $957.00 each month on your debts.  Then Jill added $500.00 to that by bringing in some extra money.  That's $1457.00 that you have available, but that you're already used to paying out.  What we do now is, take that payment and pay it to your savings instead of to debts."

"That makes sense.  How long do we do it for?"

"Well, if we subtract your debt payments, and your payroll deductions, we're left needing $3050 per month for your current living expenses.  So in a year you'll have six months' expenses banked."  Richard handed over the notebook.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Money Management Part Five - Make a Plan to Reduce Debt

For the next four days, we are coming back to the financial world of Jack and Jill.  We'll go along with them as they become the masters of their money, eliminate debt and get securely on the path to financial freedom.



"Now," Richard looked serious.  "We need to get you on track to tackle your debts.   Have you ever heard of a 'debt snowball'?"

"A what?" Jack shook his head.

"This is something that will change the way you look at money.  Forever."  Jane pulled out a sheet with figures on it.  "I did some math for you so that you can see what we're talking about."

Jack took the page and he and Jill looked it over.  "Okay, what are we looking at?"

Jane and Richard pulled their chairs closer. "Let's go through this," he said.  "At the top we have your debts listed."

Account Balance Interest Rate Payment
Line of Credit              9,000.00 9.00%         270.00
MasterCard              2,400.00 18.00%           72.00
Visa              3,000.00 19.00%           90.00
Student Loan              9,000.00 7.00%         155.00
Car Loan            11,000.00 10.00%         280.00
Other              3,000.00 24.00%           90.00
Total Payment
957.00


"Next we have the payout schedule for all of these, assuming you continue making the payments you are making right now - that means keeping your payment the same, not reducing it according to the statement,"  Richard explained.

Account Balance Interest Paid Months Paid Off
Line of Credit              9,000.00              1,395.58 39 Jun-14
MasterCard              2,400.00                952.18 47 Feb-15
Visa              3,000.00              1,298.71 48 Mar-15
Student Loan              9,000.00              2,021.05 72 Mar-17
Car Loan            11,000.00              2,380.56 48 Mar-15
Other              3,000.00              1,993.24 56 Nov-15
Total Interest Paid:  10,041.32


"Yuck."  Jill grimaced.  "That's a lot of money spent on nothing... and we're going to be paying on these debts for another six years!!"

"Well, it could be worse, you know."  Jane pointed to the next table on the page.  "This is what would happen if you made only the minimum payments due as each statement came in."
 Balance  Interest Rate  Min Payment  # Months to Pay  Total Interest Paid 
Line of Credit  $        9,000.00 9% 3% 166  $    2,910.85
MasterCard  $        2,400.00 18% 3% 151  $    2,098.29
Visa  $        3,000.00 19% 3% 174  $    3,010.46
Student Loan  $        9,000.00 7%  $            155.00 72  $    2,020.85
Car Loan  $      11,000.00 10%  $            280.00 48  $    2,380.47
Other  $        3,000.00 24% 3% 234  $    5,332.23
 $  17,753.15


"Oh my gosh... that's... that's crazy!" Jill was stunned.  "So if we just keep making minimum payments, we're going to be paying on these debts for... how long is that?"

"Your last bill will be paid in nineteen and a half years... right about the time your oldest is graduating university."  Richard looked grim.  "The sad thing is, this is exactly what most people will do.  The minimum payment fits their budget, so they pay it.  They have adopted the mentality that 'if I can afford the payment, I can afford to buy it' - but you can see the results."

"Yeah.  Wow."  Jack looked a little overwhelmed by what he was seeing.  "But we can change that.  Just by continuing to make the payments we are making right now, we're saving ourselves over $7,000 and 13 years of payments.  I'm in for that!"

"Wait, though.  It gets better.  Check this out."  Jane pulled out a new page and laid it beside the first.  "Look what happens if we change things up a bit."   The new page had the words 'Debt Snowball' written across the top, and a new chart below.

Account Balance Interest Paid Months Paid Off
MasterCard              2,400.00                924.98 41 Aug-14
Visa              3,000.00              1,267.15 42 Sep-14
Other              3,000.00              1,859.96 44 Nov-14
Line of Credit              9,000.00              1,395.58 39 Jun-14
Student Loan              9,000.00              1,766.64 50 May-15
Car Loan            11,000.00              2,380.56 48 Mar-15
Total Interest Paid: 
9,594.87

"Nice!  How does this work?"  Jack was interested.  "This has shaved what, another 22 months off the payment schedule.  How?"

Richard grinned.  "This is the power of the snowball.  What happens here is this - you continue making your payments as you are right now.  Then, a few years from now when your line of credit is paid off, you take the $270.00 you were paying on it and you add that amount to the payment on the MasterCard.  That gets paid off in two months, then you take that total payment and apply it to the Visa for one month.  And you continue rolling the payments into the next debt until they are all cleared.  You can see how fast it all happens... it's like a snowball rolling downhill.  It starts out slow and small, but it gets bigger and faster as it approaches the bottom until it is a real force."

"I can see that.  Impressive!"  Jack had caught Richard's enthusiasm.  "Is there a way to make this even better?"

Richard laughed.  "I was waiting for you to ask that!  Let's take another look at this.  The basic idea of a debt snowball is that you start with the account with the lowest balance and pay them off in succession, ending with the biggest.  Now sometimes, like in your case, you'll actually end up with a bigger account paid off first, just because the payment on it is bigger.  And that's fine!  The idea behind paying the smallest bills first is just that it gives you the psychological boost of visible progress - those celebrations are great, but once you have the fever, you'll be hooked anyway!

"Now, if we want to make this even better, we need to be more aggressive.  The most obvious way to do that is to throw more money at the problem.  I don't want to tell you to cut your budget further right away, even though there is still plenty of wiggle room there.  It won't take long for you to get a handle on your spending and find more ways to save.  But that part is up to you.  The other way is to generate more income.  Any ideas?"

"Actually, yes!" Jill interjected.  "We were looking at me going to work..."   She noticed Jane shaking her head.  "No, no, don't worry - we figured out that it wasn't going to be worth it.  But what we did decide is that I will hang out my shingle again to take in a bit of bookkeeping work.  I can work from home in the evening or during the kids' quiet time, and put in a few hours on the weekend.  I've already had a few calls just by word-of-mouth, and it looks like we can count on my bringing in about $500 per month, working a number of ours that we're comfortable with."

(Missed the last series?  Check out "But I HAVE to work!!" to see why it wouldn't pay off for Jill to get a job.)

"That's great!  And did you know that by doing that, you'll be able to write off a portion of your home expenses?"  Richard asked.

"I had heard something about that, yes, but I don't know all the details.  Maybe we can have another meeting about that down the road a bit?"  Jill smiled hopefully.

"But of course!"  Richard picked up a cookie.  "Especially if you keep baking like this when we are coming over!"   They all laughed.  "All right then, let's look at the effect of this.  Let's say you bring in $500.00.  I'd like to see you take some of that and build an emergency fund, but first we need to tackle this debt more aggressively.  Especially that appliance loan."  Jill nodded.  "When do you start?"

"This week, actually."

"Excellent.  All right, here's what we need to do.  Some of this advice is a little unconventional, but we need to get rid of that loan before the end of November.  First off, I want you to take your entire $500 and pay it on this loan in August, September, October and November.  Then in November, before the due date on the loan, I want you to use your line of credit and pay this account off.  You'll have paid $1080 onto your line of credit by then, and you said there was a bit of room on it already, right?"

"Yes."

"Then this should work.  You will probably need to come up with a couple hundred extra by then to settle the whole balance - can you do that?  If there is even a few dollars left on this account on its due date, you'll be on the hook for about $1500 in interest."

"We can do it.  Thank you so much... we had no idea that loan would end up costing us so much!"  Jill was encouraged.  "What do we do next?"

"Well, once that one is out of the way, we continue with the snowball.  You take the $90.00 that you were paying on the furniture, and you apply it to the MasterCard.  Now you're paying $162.00 on that account.  It will be paid off next April.  When that is paid off you take that $162.00 and add it to the payment on the Visa - now you're paying $252.00 on that account, which will have it paid off in December.  Next, you take that $252.00 and add it to the payment on the line of credit, paying $522.00 until the following September when it will be paid off.  Then you roll that $522.00 over onto the Student Loan, paying $677.00 on it until the following April, when you take that payment and add it to your car, paying the car off the very next month.    Following this track, we'll have you out of debt in under four years, and saving literally thousands more in interest.

"Also, in December and January, you take your $500.00 from your business and you build yourselves an emergency fund in the bank.  You want to see it be at least $1000.00 set aside, so that when something happens you'll have the cash on hand to take care of it and you won't have to dip into your credit again.  Once that is in place, let's throw it all at your debt.  What do you suppose that would do for you?"

Jill could see that Jack was getting a taste for freedom.  "Do tell," she replied.

"Well, by adding $500 worth of snowflakes to that snowball each month, starting in February, we bring you down to just 31 months of payments, and you'll only be paying a couple thousand dollars in interest."

"Amazing.  So... after that... we'll have freed up $957 each month.  $1457 if Jill keeps working. That would make life a lot easier!!"  Jack enthused.

"Hold on, pal - we're not through with this yet!" Richard was jotting numbers on a page.  "What do you think you should do with that money?"

"Well, the car could stand to be replaced... there are things around the house that I'd like to finish up..."

Richard cut Jack off.  "Don't get ahead of yourself there, Jack.  We've got a few more things to work through yet before we get to that point."  

Jack looked confused. "But..."

"Do you really think $1,000 in the bank is enough?"

"Well... it's more than we have now... but I'm guessing the answer is no?"

"Definitely not.  Your next goal needs to be savings.  But for now, let's wrap things up and get you moving with your debt plan.  Deal?"  Richard stuck out his hand.

"Deal."  Jack shook his friend's hand.  "And thanks.  This is amazing.  Really.  I feel like a load of concrete has been lifted off my shoulders... not to mention feeling like someone just turned on the lights.  Man, it's crazy that we didn't see any of this before.  Most people don't, though, do they?"

"Sadly, no... that's why we've become rather passionate about this.  We want to see our friends get to where we are."  Jill smiled.  "And you guys are well on your way already!"


Get Out of Debt with the Debt Snowball Plan
The Truth About Debt Consolidation

Downloads:
Debt Reduction Calculator